Which is the better deal to make?

Ottoneu Fantasy Baseball
1

Deal A:
Paul Skenes ($33)
Jeff McNeil ($1)
For
Bryan Woo ($12)
Jackson Merrill ($10)
Mick Abel ($4)
Roman Anthony ($3)

Deal B:
Paul Skenes ($33)
Jeff McNeil ($1)
For
Jasson Dominguez ($10)
Jackson Holliday ($9)
Andrew Abbott ($4)
Andrew Painter ($4)

I am the team offering up Paul Skenes and Jeff McNeil.. I’d like to know from the Ottoneu Community, which is the better deal to make…

2

Neither. I would keep Skenes.

3

First one by far. I would personally do it, pitchers break all the time. But that’s just me

3 Likes
4

The return on Deal A is very solid value for Skenes. I would personally take that offer in a heartbeat.

2 Likes
5

Deal A. Even if Abel wasn’t included, I’d make the trade. The fact that he is is a bonus. Also Skenes will probably get loaded during arbitration.

2 Likes
6

Agreed. That’s a really solid package.

Dominguez is really the only guy I like in B and that’s not enough for Skenes. Holliday to me seems like he’s going to be Gavin Lux, not a star.

7

I’d do deal A. I would probably keep Skenes or shop elsewhere before taking deal B.